Optometrist.reviews
Vision Care Experts
Home/States/New York/Leicester

The Best Optometrists in Leicester, NY

Compare 3 verified eye care professionals in Leicester. Read reviews, check credentials, and find the perfect optometrist for your vision needs.

3
Optometrists
4.8
Average Rating
285
Total Reviews

Verified Eye Care Professionals

1

Dr. Mark D. Matteson

Geneseo Family Eyecare

★★★★☆
4.8/5

Dr. Mark Matteson leads this highly-rated family practice located just 6 miles from Leicester. With over two decades of experience, he has built a reputation for thorough comprehensive eye examinations and personalized patient care. The practice specializes in managing ocular diseases like glaucoma and diabetic retinopathy while offering advanced contact lens fittings. Patients consistently praise the friendly staff, modern equipment, and Dr. Matteson's detailed explanations. The practice serves patients of all ages with particular expertise in pediatric eye care and accepts most major insurance plans.

Experience:25 years
Reviews:87 patient reviews
4242 Lakeville Rd, Geneseo, NY 14454

Services:

Comprehensive eye examscontact lens fittingspediatric eye careglaucoma managementcataract co-management
2

Dr. Michael J. Rago

Avon Vision Center

★★★★☆
4.7/5

Located approximately 8 miles from Leicester in Avon, Dr. Michael Rago's practice has served the Livingston County community for nearly two decades. The practice is known for its comprehensive approach to eye health, including emergency eye care services and advanced dry eye treatments. Dr. Rago provides detailed LASIK consultations and co-management, along with specialized sports vision services. Patients frequently mention the comfortable office environment, minimal wait times, and Dr. Rago's attentive approach to addressing all vision concerns. The practice utilizes state-of-the-art diagnostic technology.

Experience:20 years
Reviews:42 patient reviews
55 Genesee St, Avon, NY 14414

Services:

Comprehensive eye careemergency eye servicesLASIK consultationsdry eye treatmentsports vision
3

Dr. David A. Damico

Rochester Ophthalmological Group

★★★★☆
4.9/5

While located in Rochester (approximately 35 miles from Leicester), Dr. David Damico and the Rochester Ophthalmological Group serve patients throughout the region, including Livingston County. This practice offers the highest level of medical eye care with multiple specialists on staff. Dr. Damico specializes in complex medical cases including diabetic retinopathy, macular degeneration, and retinal diseases. The practice features the most advanced diagnostic technology available and provides comprehensive surgical co-management. Patients travel from throughout Western New York for their expertise in managing challenging eye conditions and complex prescriptions.

Experience:22 years
Reviews:156 patient reviews
919 Westfall Rd, Rochester, NY 14618

Services:

Medical eye examssurgical co-managementdiabetic eye caremacular degeneration treatmentretinal diseases

Frequently Asked Questions

How can I find a reputable optometrist serving the Leicester, NY area?

For Leicester residents, a good starting point is to ask for recommendations from your primary care physician at Livingston County Health Department or from neighbors in the Leicester community. You can also use online directories from your vision insurance provider, filtering for providers within a 15-20 mile radius, as many optometrists in nearby Geneseo, Mount Morris, or Dansville serve the Leicester area. Checking reviews on local community Facebook groups or the 'Leicester NY Community Page' can provide personal insights into patient experiences with specific eye doctors in the region.

What specific eye care services should I expect from an optometrist in a rural town like Leicester?

Optometrists with practices near Leicester, NY, typically offer comprehensive eye exams, prescriptions for glasses and contact lenses, and management of common conditions like dry eye, glaucoma, and diabetic eye disease. Given the area's rural nature, many also prioritize detecting conditions prevalent in agricultural communities, such as injuries from foreign bodies or UV exposure. However, for specialized surgical consultations or advanced retinal treatments, they will refer patients to ophthalmology centers in larger nearby cities like Rochester or Buffalo. It's wise to confirm if a practice offers on-site optical services or works with a local frame vendor, as immediate access to eyewear can be limited.

Do optometrists near Leicester, NY accept my vision insurance?

Acceptance varies by practice. Most optometry offices in the Leicester vicinity, including those in neighboring towns, commonly accept major insurance plans like VSP, EyeMed, and Davis Vision, as well as Medicare for medically necessary exams. It's crucial to call the specific office ahead of your appointment. Be prepared to provide your insurance details, as some smaller rural practices may be in-network with certain regional provider networks. Also, inquire about self-pay options or payment plans, as not all services may be fully covered, especially for specialized contact lens fittings.

What are the typical costs for an eye exam without insurance in the Leicester area?

In the Leicester and surrounding Livingston County region, a comprehensive eye exam for glasses typically ranges from $90 to $150 without insurance. A contact lens fitting is an additional fee, usually between $50 and $120, depending on the complexity (e.g., toric for astigmatism or multifocal). Prices may be slightly lower than in major metropolitan areas like Rochester but can vary between independent practices and larger optical chains in nearby retail hubs. Always ask for a complete price estimate upfront, including any retinal imaging or diagnostic tests, which may incur extra charges.

How far in advance do I need to book an appointment with an optometrist serving Leicester, NY?

For routine eye exams, booking 2 to 4 weeks in advance is common for optometrists in the Leicester area, especially for popular times like after-school hours or Saturdays. Demand can be higher at the end of the year when patients use remaining insurance benefits. For urgent issues like eye infections or sudden vision changes, many practices reserve slots for same-day or next-day appointments for established patients, so it's important to call as soon as the office opens. Given the rural setting, consider travel time to offices in adjacent towns when scheduling, and ask about telehealth options for preliminary consultations or follow-ups.

Best Optometrists in Leicester, NY | The Top 3