Optometrist.reviews
Vision Care Experts

The Best Optometrists in Edinburg, PA

Compare 3 verified eye care professionals in Edinburg. Read reviews, check credentials, and find the perfect optometrist for your vision needs.

3
Optometrists
4.7
Average Rating
137
Total Reviews

Verified Eye Care Professionals

1

Dr. John A. Caroselli

Caroselli Eye Care

★★★★☆
4.8/5

Dr. John A. Caroselli has been providing exceptional eye care to the Edinburg and greater Lawrence County area for over two decades. His practice is highly rated for its thorough comprehensive exams, advanced diagnostic technology, and family-friendly approach. Patients consistently praise the personalized care, safety protocols, and expertise in managing conditions like glaucoma and fitting contact lenses for all ages. The practice maintains a strong record of patient satisfaction and community trust.

Experience:24 years
Reviews:52 patient reviews
1202 Wilmington Road, New Castle, PA 16105

Services:

Comprehensive Eye ExamsContact Lens FittingPediatric Eye CareGlaucoma Management
2

Dr. Mark A. Fronzaglia

Fronzaglia Eye Care

★★★★☆
4.7/5

Dr. Mark A. Fronzaglia leads a well-established practice known for its high-quality care and patient-centered services. With over 20 years of experience, the practice excels in routine eye exams, dry eye management, and pre- and post-cataract care. It features modern amenities, a comfortable environment, and a dedicated staff, earning strong reviews for safety, family satisfaction, and comprehensive optical services. The practice serves Edinburg residents with reliability and expertise.

Experience:22 years
Reviews:38 patient reviews
1906 Wilmington Road, New Castle, PA 16105

Services:

Routine Eye ExamsDry Eye TreatmentCataract ConsultationsOptical Services
3

Dr. James R. McQuiston

McQuiston Eye Care

★★★★☆
4.6/5

Dr. James R. McQuiston operates a reputable practice with nearly two decades of service to the Edinburg and surrounding communities. Specializing in vision therapy, diabetic eye exams, and urgent eye care, the practice is praised for its skilled staff, state-of-the-art equipment, and compassionate approach. High ratings reflect excellent safety records, family-oriented care, and a wide range of eyewear options. Patients value the practice's longevity and commitment to community eye health.

Experience:18 years
Reviews:47 patient reviews
1009 South Mill Street, New Castle, PA 16101

Services:

Vision TherapyDiabetic Eye ExamsEmergency Eye CareEyewear Selection

Frequently Asked Questions

How can I find a reputable optometrist in or near Edinburg, PA?

Start by asking for recommendations from your primary care doctor at local clinics or from neighbors in the Edinburg area. You can also search online directories like the Pennsylvania Optometric Association's 'Find a Doctor' tool, filtering for Lawrence County. Checking reviews for practices in nearby communities like New Castle, Ellwood City, or New Wilmington that serve Edinburg residents is also helpful. Many local optometrists have strong community ties and participate in health fairs.

What eye care services are typically available from optometrists serving the Edinburg community?

Optometrists in the Edinburg area provide comprehensive eye exams, prescriptions for glasses and contact lenses, and management of common eye conditions like dry eye, glaucoma, and diabetic eye disease. Given the rural setting, many also prioritize detecting conditions that can be managed locally before they require a specialist trip to Pittsburgh. Some practices may offer a wider selection of frames on-site or have partnerships with optical labs for timely service, which is valuable for residents without easy access to large shopping centers.

Do optometrists near Edinburg, PA accept my vision or medical insurance?

Most optometry practices in the Edinburg/New Castle area accept major vision plans (like VSP or EyeMed) and medical insurance (like Highmark, UPMC Health Plan). However, due to the variety of individual plans and employer contracts, it's crucial to call the specific office beforehand. Confirm they are in-network for your plan and ask about coverage for your exam type (routine vision vs. medical). Some smaller local practices may also offer competitive self-pay rates or payment plans for uninsured patients.

What should I consider when choosing between optometry practices in the Edinburg area?

Consider proximity and convenience, as you may need follow-up visits. Check the optometrist's experience and if they have specific expertise relevant to you (e.g., pediatric eye care, managing ocular disease). Evaluate the practice's hours to fit your schedule and their policy on handling emergencies. Since Edinburg is a smaller borough, many patients also value a practice's reputation for personalized, friendly service and whether they offer a good selection of eyewear without needing to travel far. The availability of modern diagnostic technology is another key factor.

How far in advance do I typically need to book an eye exam with an optometrist near Edinburg, PA?

For a routine comprehensive eye exam, booking 2 to 4 weeks in advance is common for popular optometrists in the Lawrence County area. New patient appointments may require more lead time. For urgent concerns (like sudden vision changes or eye injuries), most practices will work to see you the same day or within 24 hours—be sure to clearly state the urgency when calling. Scheduling can be more flexible during certain times of the year, so it's worth asking about cancellation lists if you need an earlier appointment.

Best Optometrists in Edinburg, PA | The Top 3