Optometrist.reviews
Vision Care Experts

The Best Optometrists in New Albany, PA

Compare 3 verified eye care professionals in New Albany. Read reviews, check credentials, and find the perfect optometrist for your vision needs.

3
Optometrists
4.6
Average Rating
265
Total Reviews

Verified Eye Care Professionals

1

Dr. David C. Colyer

Colyer Eye Care

★★★★☆
4.6/5

Dr. David C. Colyer at Colyer Eye Care is a highly respected optometrist serving the New Albany area with over 19 years of experience. The practice is known for its exceptional care quality, with a focus on personalized patient attention and advanced diagnostic technology. Patients consistently praise the friendly staff, thorough eye exams, and family-friendly environment. The practice maintains an excellent safety record and offers a wide range of services including pediatric eye care and management of ocular diseases. With numerous positive reviews highlighting their professionalism and compassionate care, Colyer Eye Care has built a strong reputation in the community since its founding in 2005.

Experience:19 years
Reviews:85 patient reviews
101 Main Street, Towanda, PA 18848

Services:

Comprehensive eye examscontact lens fittingspediatric eye careglaucoma testingdry eye treatment
2

Dr. Jennifer L. Miller

Miller Eye Care

★★★★☆
4.4/5

Dr. Jennifer L. Miller leads Miller Eye Care, providing top-tier optometry services to the New Albany region since 2010. With 14 years of experience, Dr. Miller is recognized for her expertise in contact lens fittings and emergency eye care. The practice emphasizes patient safety and comfort, utilizing modern equipment for accurate diagnoses. Reviews frequently mention the warm, welcoming atmosphere and the staff's dedication to patient education. Families appreciate the comprehensive care for all ages, and the practice has a strong track record of satisfaction among local residents. Their commitment to quality eye health services makes them a reliable choice for the community.

Experience:14 years
Reviews:60 patient reviews
200 North Elmer Avenue, Sayre, PA 18840

Services:

Routine eye examscontact lens evaluationsemergency eye carepre- and post-operative careoptical services
3

Dr. Michael T. O'Donnell

O'Donnell Eye Care

★★★★☆
4.8/5

Dr. Michael T. O'Donnell of O'Donnell Eye Care has been serving patients in and around New Albany for 16 years, earning a 4.8 rating based on extensive patient feedback. The practice is acclaimed for its high standards in care quality, including specialized services like diabetic eye care and low vision support. Patients report excellent experiences with the knowledgeable team and state-of-the-art facilities, emphasizing the practice's focus on preventive care and patient safety. Founded in 2008, O'Donnell Eye Care has built a loyal patient base through consistent, reliable service and a family-centered approach. Their robust review count reflects deep community trust and satisfaction.

Experience:16 years
Reviews:120 patient reviews
150 York Avenue, Towanda, PA 18848

Services:

Full-scope eye examsdiabetic eye carelow vision servicessports vision trainingadvanced contact lens options

Frequently Asked Questions

How can I find a reputable optometrist in or near New Albany, PA?

In the New Albany area, a good starting point is to ask for recommendations from your primary care physician at Guthrie or from local pharmacists. You can also use the provider search tools of major Pennsylvania health insurers like Highmark Blue Shield or Capital Blue Cross, filtering for optometrists in zip codes 18810 (New Albany) or nearby towns like Towanda or Wyalusing. Checking online reviews for practices in Bradford County can provide additional patient perspectives.

What specific eye care services are typically offered by optometrists in the New Albany region?

Optometrists serving New Albany and rural Bradford County typically provide comprehensive eye exams, prescriptions for glasses and contact lenses, and diagnosis/managing of common conditions like dry eye, glaucoma, and diabetic eye disease. Given the area's demographics, many also specialize in managing age-related vision changes like cataracts and macular degeneration. Some practices may offer pediatric eye care. Due to the rural setting, it's important to confirm if a practice offers advanced diagnostic testing on-site or if they coordinate with ophthalmologists in larger centers like Sayre or Scranton for specialized care.

Do optometrists in New Albany, PA accept my vision or medical insurance?

Most optometry practices in the New Albany area accept a range of insurance plans common to Pennsylvania and the Northern Tier region. This typically includes Medicare, Medicaid (through Pennsylvania's Physical HealthChoices plans), and major commercial insurers like Highmark, UPMC Health Plan, and Aetna. It is highly recommended to call the specific practice before scheduling an appointment. Be sure to ask if they are in-network for both your medical insurance (for health-related eye issues) and your separate vision insurance plan (for routine exams and lenses), as coverage can differ.

What should I consider when choosing between the optometrists available in the New Albany area?

When choosing an optometrist in this rural area, key considerations include: proximity and travel time, as some residents may need to drive to neighboring towns; the range of in-office technology available (like retinal imaging); the optometrist's experience with any specific eye conditions you may have; office hours that accommodate your schedule; and whether they have an optical shop on-site for convenience. Also, consider if the practice's philosophy aligns with your needs—some may focus more on medical eye care, while others might emphasize a wide selection of eyewear.

How far in advance do I typically need to book an eye exam with an optometrist in New Albany, PA?

Appointment availability can vary in the New Albany region. For a routine comprehensive eye exam, it's common to schedule 2 to 6 weeks in advance, especially for popular times like after-school hours or Saturdays. For more urgent, non-emergency concerns (like sudden eye irritation or a broken glasses prescription), many practices will try to accommodate patients sooner, often within a week. It's advisable to plan ahead, particularly if you need an exam for a specific deadline, such as a driver's license renewal or the start of the school year. Calling practices in the late summer or early fall may reveal longer wait times due to back-to-school demand.

Best Optometrists in New Albany, PA | The Top 3